Feb 19, 2024
19 mins read
19 mins read

How to Decide if an English Cottage Garden Is Right for You

How to Decide if an English Cottage Garden Is Right for You

5 Key Characteristics of a Cottage-Style Garden

  1. Hardscape details: A picket fence, an iron gate, a brick or stone pathway, and a traditional arched arbor can instantly create the feeling of a quaint, old-time garden. Benches, flower urns, other garden accessories and structures heighten the sense of style underpinning the plantings.
  2. An abundance of plants: "Abundance," "exuberance," and "jumbled" are all words to describe the way the plants fill and overflow the flowerbeds. Be sure to use enough of one type of plant to give a full look without a confused look at the odds and ends of plants tossed together. There is a method to the madness of such places: make drifts of grouped plants in odd numbers like five or seven.
  3. Roses: The planting scheme will benefit from the addition of roses. The heritage/heirloom types with many petals or, conversely, simple single roses, especially. Climbing and shrub types give the architectural grace that was seen around these traditional homes.
  4. Careful maintenance: Intensively cultivated, regular maintenance of plants, soil and weeding is needed when flowers are grown this way. This nostalgic style is a labor of love—the love of the plants!
  5. Traditional architecture: The look best matches traditional architecture, like Cape Cod, English Tudor, and other such homes. Reconciling the sleeker, modern-style homes is more of a challenge. It will require some modification to meld the house with its surroundings.
  6. Get advice on how to determine if the English cottage garden style is a good fit for your yard.

This Style Speaks of Simpler Times

What's the secret to designing these charming spaces?

Everybody loves the quaint cottage gardens they see in pictures or happily chance to visit. There is something warm and welcoming about the traditional ones that remind us of simpler times, grandmother's borders, full of an overflow of flowers and fruits to gather on a summer's day.

  • How easy is it to create or care for one?
  • Does this landscape match the style of your home?
  • Will it work to tuck one into a corner if at odds with the house facade?

Such outdoor spaces have certain plants that give the style its own unmistakable look. These are rooted in the history of England's farmers and villagers. Will those plants match the landscape needs of your site?

Discover: Suitability for Your Site

Let's walk together into these quaint front yards, through their gates and around their pathways.

Maybe such a plan is perfect for your own home landscape. Or if not, you can enjoy our guided tour through this old-time enclosure fairly bursting with fruits, flowering bushes and fragrant blooms. Certainly, a place to dream about . . . but is it the one for your home?

A lovely cottage garden path

A lovely cottage garden path

Tideswell by tom heyes

Historical Background

These were originally the food and flower patch of everyday tenant farmers, those who worked on other people's lands but had a little house and yard of their own.

  • They were small, practical plots meant for feeding and supporting the family.
  • They were intensively cultivated; every little plant was placed cheek by jowl to make the best use of the small space afforded. This meant that the plantings were mixed: fruit trees, small fruits, medicinal and culinary herbs, and a few pretty things thrown in just for the love of it.
  • Originally these areas adjacent to the house were meant to be low maintenance, with the main effort dedicated to the kitchen vegetables and fruits.
  • It is only in relatively modern times that the "tidy mess" became a complicated endeavor of constant flowering.

As the Victorian era reached a frenzy of decoration and love of the exotic and the oddity, there grew a hunger for these more humble flowerbed designs. Quietly maintained by country folk who had remained unchanged by the whims of fashion, influential gardeners took notice.

William Robinson, Tastemaker

A tastemaker, William Robinson, wrote passionately about these older types of gardens and their simpler flowers and abundant plantings.

Gertrude Jekyll joined the movement, which swept away the bedding and parterres to a large degree and implemented their ideals of a picturesque and more artistically natural feel of style.

Roses and clematis grow up around the stone dwelling.

How This Style Developed

Many of what we call "English gardens" have a distinctive form of naturalistic planting that takes its cue from the old dwellings of small English villages.

The English style can vary widely from the grand, sweeping estates of the landscape movement of Capability Brown to the more "gardenesque" styles of the Victorian age. They also include this form which we love so well.

Edwardians Needed a More Natural Look

The growth of the middle class coincided with the popular sentiment to create a home with a garden that included the natural look of the old familiar flowers. The rigid regimentation of plants in rows, bedding out, or tightly manicured flower beds gave way to the more romantic freedom of William Robinson's vision.

William Robinson wrote "The Wild Gardener" and changed the appearance of English gardening forever afterwards. He persuasively argued for the old-fashioned flowers and planting style of the traditional cottagers. It revived and became the iconic look that we equate with British landscape design today.

How This Style Developed

Many of what we call "English gardens" have a distinctive form of naturalistic planting that takes its cue from the old dwellings of small English villages.

The English style can vary widely from the grand, sweeping estates of the landscape movement of Capability Brown to the more "gardenesque" styles of the Victorian age. They also include this form which we love so well.

Edwardians Needed a More Natural Look

The growth of the middle class coincided with the popular sentiment to create a home with a garden that included the natural look of the old familiar flowers. The rigid regimentation of plants in rows, bedding out, or tightly manicured flower beds gave way to the more romantic freedom of William Robinson's vision.

William Robinson wrote "The Wild Gardener" and changed the appearance of English gardening forever afterwards. He persuasively argued for the old-fashioned flowers and planting style of the traditional cottagers. It revived and became the iconic look that we equate with British landscape design today.

A modern home can show off tradition by harmonizing the surroundings with the architecture.

Contemporary House Design With an Old-Fashioned Garden

The modern form of this look is almost always a flowery one. While vegetables might be welcome, they are rarely included when designing such a plan. But with today's trends, it could be time to return to the former methods of growing herbs, vegetables and flowers all together.

Incorporate Food Plants

With the new emphasis on edibles in the front yard, it might be time to incorporate more of salads and herbs into the streetside landscape plans if this is your desired style. They can be almost hidden among the blooming plants, with some of the colored foliage of lettuces or chard actually adding bright color.

Selection of Location

Two good places in the landscape for such plantings might be a small area by the door, an entry area enclosed with a fence, or a border next to the driveway.

Cleome, Cosmos, Begonia, Nicotiana syvestris, Allyssum, Coreopsis

 

Cleome, Cosmos, Begonia, Nicotiana syvestris, Allyssum, Coreopsis

Bev Wagar

Harmonize Home and Yard

Most homes will harmonize with this style, but a strongly contemporary one with modern lines may be visually jarring. It has a feeling that the two aren't knit together properly. While Cape Cod style and traditional bungalows seem made for the simple cloud-like drifts of flowers and vines that comprise a proper cottage garden.

  • Generally, if you have a picket fence, you can have this sort of border! Rustic-looking fences and Craftsman-styled houses will look ideal with this abundance of plants.
  • Not for the front yard? Make a personal space hidden away in the backyard.
  • It is a tried and true method to make outdoor "rooms", sectioned off areas of the landscape to create a different sort of design from those adjacent.
  • Utilize bushes, either a shrubbery or hedge, and create your version of the style in a compartment of its own. This is one way to have your cake and eat it, too, when the house is a style that looks jarring with an overflow of flowering plants. Your own personal bower.

Is This Style for You?

Don't let the simplicity of the look fool you. These are intensively cultivated properties that require a good deal of attention and labor from the gardener. Someone who has time to work in the flowerbeds and among the vegetables, pruning the fruit trees and keeping everything healthy and in good order. Does that describe you?

It isn't an easy or maintenance-free sort of yard.

However, it is a beautiful, rewarding one.

Best Tip: Start Small

Choose an area right outside the door, or along the entry path, and begin planting a mix of herbs, annuals and low-growing perennials.

Welcoming Feeling, Well-Spaced Growth

Even the plants of these quaint plots seem to be on close and friendly terms since they are characterized by flowers bursting the seams of the boundaries.

Yet, it is important to remember that plants that are too close for comfort create conditions ripe for disease.

  • Weakened plants are struggling to get enough nutrients and moisture.
  • Air space for circulation around each plant is also desirable to keep plants growing their best.

Let your abundant flowers come from healthy, well-placed plants and not from stuffing too many plants in a cramped space.

Border of perennial plants only seems effortless. It requires careful planning and regular care.

 

Border of perennial plants only seems effortless. It requires careful planning and regular care.

Tony Hisgett

Right Plants in the Right Place

Just what makes a plant "the right one"?

Besides being suitable for your climate and soil conditions, ease of care is a factor for a busy homeowner. Plants that remain healthy without coddling, sprays, or dividing are a boon.

These qualities won't turn this high-maintenance style into a low-demand type, but it will increase its practicality for modern homeowners.

Which Perennials Are Good Choices?

Start out with stalwarts like Iris, peonies, and hardy roses, include good fillers like daisies and baby's breath (Gypsophila) and then add the accents of spires and spiky foliage plants to give height and vertical interest to the planting.

Another way to design it: choose a basic central group of flower forms and then add some from other groups to spice it up. Basic groups of flowers might be those with a daisy form, or those with a lily form, perhaps accenting with iris forms or spires of lupines.

Include the Versatile Daisy Family

The daisy group of flower forms, called the Compositae, is the largest category with an inexhaustible number of plants, including the sunflower and aster, as well as daisy groups of blooms. Many of the Compositae group make wonderful flower bed choices, with abundant growth and a cheerful look.

One of the most famous of this style is Monet's Giverny property, which is open to visit in France.

 

One of the most famous of this style is Monet's Giverny property, which is open to visit in France.

chugbot

Plants Rule

Vines drape gates, arbors and fences. Drifts of flowers fill the spaces, they are abundant and blowzy. The plants rule here! If you decided that this is the look for you, it is time to pick the herbaceous plants, shrubs and trees to grow.

Delphinium for height, mounding daisies for form and the daylily anchors the design with color and contrast.

 

Delphinium for height, mounding daisies for form and the daylily anchors the design with color and contrast.

Hemerocallis for Busy Gardeners

Daylilies (Hemerocallis) make perfect plants for traditional yet easy-care landscapes.

That makes them a great choice for today. Hardy, without disease problems, in an ever-increasing color range and form, heights, and bloom times. Hybridizers and homeowners love them because they are so accommodating to those who love both beauty and good landscaping qualities.

Easy, Long-Lived, Colorful

Hemerocallis can solve many design problems: like what to plant in the shade or near a roadway.

Once acquainted with them, you can combine the different heights and bloom periods to give a spot of color or a large drift that never seems out of bloom. The trick is to stagger the expected bloom schedule.

The daylily will bring a burst of color during the time when most of us don't want to slave outdoors.

  • Have a shady area?
  • Need color for most of the summer?
  • Don't want to have to follow a special list of maintenance tasks?

Daylilies are today's landscape choice for their healthy foliage and cheerful blooms.

Consider making this perennial the backbone of your flower bed. Combine them with spires and daisy shape blooms for contrast.

Use Annuals for Bursts of Bloom

Easy to grow flowers: just sow and grow. Find the perfect ones for a corner spot, even if you can't give over the entire yard to this type of gardening. Many books list varieties to look for: start with nigella, calendula, and Shirley Poppies.

A plentiful overflow of flowers in containers add to the full  and lush look.

 

A plentiful overflow of flowers in containers add to the full and lush look.

Classic Design Principles

"All about charm and character, still they rely on the same basic principles as any other style. Start by creating a basic shape of hard landscaping, then add 'core' trees, shrubs and perennials that give the landscape its personality. Leave the fine detail until last."

Putting the Forms Together

Different forms like spires, mounds, and vining plants are used in blocks or drifts, with no less than three to five plants of the same type together. Hollyhocks and sunflowers give height, while phlox paniculata or daylilies provide color, and larkspurs or foxgloves give a vertical line for variation.

Don't be dotty about it; place groupings for the best effect with contrasts of form and texture.

A flower-covered gate is an inviting touch.

Add a Welcoming Gate

An inviting gate will give form to the entrance and a frame for the abundant flowers that you can't wait to plant all around it. It is detail like arbors, fences, pathways and gates that give evocative focal points to your plantings.

Create an authentic feeling with an inviting gate entry. Pickets, lattice and supports will all evoke the traditional yards of yesteryear when such boundaries were an important protection of the cottager's kitchen vegetables and simples.

Rose-Covered Arch

One of the most iconic features is a rose-covered arch leading from the front walk to the door or as an entry into another part of the property. It was a Gertrude Jekyll favorite, to include in her designs along with specific suggestions on just which climbing roses to add. (Roses were almost always the plant of choice).

Today gardeners have a much easier time choosing a desirable climber from the world-famous breeding of David Austin. He creates roses that have the form and fragrance of the heirlooms, but with the blooming qualities of the modern ones.

Such simple structures give so much charm to a landscape.

Vintage accessories help create the right atmosphere, along with the plants and hardscaping.

The Heirloom Plants

Heirlooms are the ones that originally populated the old places. Passed on through generations, saved for their qualities that ranged from flowers of unusual colors to produce of exceptional taste.

A Full-Blown Shrub Rose Anchors the Plan

'Carding Mill' is a variety that will quickly make a bushy, rounded shrub up to 4 feet tall. This full shape is what makes a great heirloom rose.

A myrrh fragrance and many-petaled blooms are the old-fashioned part of this rose, while the all-season blooms and warm apricot color are products of modern breeding.

Today's shrub roses are bred to give healthy foliage, shrub qualities, and a long season of bloom. These are not the spindly hybrid teas that need coddling and constant spraying.

Include at least one in your plan.

Abraham Darby Is a Prime Candidate for Entries

One of the most recommended shrub-style roses has to be the 'Abraham Darby' English Rose.

Nothing blooms for a longer season than rose bushes. Consider pairing them with daisies and campanulas for a cheerful bed of long-lasting blooms.

This Rose Has Fragrance, Presence and Beauty

This variety is one of the more hardy and healthy varieties of the David Austin English Roses. Fruity fragrance and good health make it a winner. Shrub roses are one of the major plants to make a garden of this type look authentic and traditional.

Fruit or Flowering Trees? Or Both?

Ornamental trees are smaller in mature size and provide seasonal color.

Smaller trees, especially if they are filled with fragrant spring blooms, are ideal plantings for a cottage-style place.

Choose Dwarf Trees

If you are interested in harvesting fruit, there are many dwarf varieties to choose from. Barring that, the art of espalier reduces the size of a tree while generating perfect conditions for fruit. They are labor-intensive with particular care to the pruning techniques.

Most homeowners would be happiest with small ornamental trees because they allow more sun and nutrients to be available for plantings surrounding them. Fruit trees require a great deal of care in terms of spraying, pruning, harvesting, which isn't ideal if only a landscaping feature is desirable. However, they are of the utmost priority if you wish to provide for your table.

A small lemon tree.

 

A small lemon tree.

Add Color, Fragrance, Taste

Cherries

Cherry trees are ideal. They bear fruit, they are full of spring blooms, and they make handsome trees with year-round interest with their shiny, mahogany-colored bark. If you have a large enough yard you may grow a sweet cherry that is self-fertile like the 'Stella' variety, otherwise it is best to plant one of the tart pie cherry trees.

Pears

If you like pears, chose one of the dwarf varieties that have a reputation to taste good. They are pretty and bloom abundantly in the spring. Don't plant where dropping fruit would create a problem, such as near a driveway.

Peaches

Peach trees are usually smaller in size, and they need consistent pruning. Remember their large soft fruits and don't plant where they could be a nuisance. They have a lovely pink bloom in the spring and come in dwarf sizes for smaller spaces.

Birds Love Fruits, Too

While these suggestions would be an authentic feature, for some modern landscapes and schedules an ornamental tree is best.

Fruit trees can be messy, and if you are not interested in harvesting the produce, there is no reason to put up with the care that they need.

The Old-Fashioned Flowers

Many of these heirloom plants are easy to grow and care for, that is one of their attractions.

A few additional tips:

  • Choosing the right plants, and cultivating them well, is important.
  • With some guidance and your own loving labors, you will soon make a scene like this bloom outside your own windows. Visually rewarding, they are a great showcase for the person who loves to put time into their yard.
  • Perennial plants are the backbone of a beautiful, lasting design, and a good resource book is almost as important a tool as your spade.
  • Learn how to put together a plan with charm and an English village look: videos and books help with the ideas and layouts. Remember that plants can be moved around when the results don't look as planned. Have some fun with the process.